Menu

OPUS 3 : Oil Paintings Under Scrutiny : Mona Lisa / da Vinci

I suppose it is inevitable that I would want to critique what is commonly recognized as the greatest painting of all time, the "Mona Lisa" by Leonardo da Vinci.  Foolish, perhaps, but inevitable. 

 

 

Mona Lisa

Artist: Leonardo da Vinci

1503-1506

 

Ok...

 

So this is a portrait painted 515 years ago by a genius from another country.  Perhaps it rings clearer if I said this painting last smelled fresh over five centuries ago.  Tastes evolve, cultures churn, the likes and dislikes of those with control of the media rule the history that survives. Women with a gap between their two front teeth were highly desirable in Chaucer's time. Full-figured women laying about on velvet couches were all the rage at some point.  Men who wore paper clown collars in the Netherlands were considered very dignified at one point.  In France, dusty white wigs were accoutrements of the upper crust. My point is simply that for a man -a non-qualified man I might add- to evaluate anything from five centuries ago is fraught with the distortions of all that cultural churning without adding on the subjectivity with which this evaluation is generated and the relative authority, or lack thereof, of the critic. 

 

Regarding SKILL, it is quite obvious that Leonardo was master of his brushes. I am personally imagining that the colors were three times more vivid in 1504 than now. However, I am not impressed with the colors overall, even if her clothes were all the rage in Florence. Leonardo should have certainly suggested a colorful scarf or a white cat to sit on her lap for the minute accent to lightly offset the heaviness of all that brown. The accuracy can only be assumed, of course, but there is something about her decolletage that doesn't seem quite right to me.  I'm looking for the shortcomings, as I see them, given that I am critiquing a painting insured for over 800 million dollars. 

 

I see nothing glaring about Leonardo's edges, albeit this is a portrait and not a stylistic display of creativity. His intent was certainly met. I would not likely be attracted to this painting from across a room.  I cannot in good faith proclaim that this painting is beautiful, despite reputable opinions to the contrary down through the centuries. Had I an evaluation category that captured the feeling of connectedness with an artist five centuries ago, then this would be as highly rated as cave drawings.  I see little creativity except for the possibility that in his day this portrait was considered wonderfully creative. 

 

Skill: 27 out of 50

Creativity: 13 out of 25

Aesthetics: 20 out of 25

OPUS: 60 out of 100

 

OPUS 100

Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post